Best Peanut Butter for Dogs

As a Co-founder of Spread The Love and a lifelong dog lover, I get asked this question often: “Is peanut butter safe for dogs?” The short answer is yes... If you pick the right peanut butter for dogs! Peanut butter with no xylitol, sugar, or palm oil can be a delicious, protein-packed way to reward your pup. But the wrong jar can lead to hypoglycemia, pancreatitis, or obesity.

I believe our pets deserve the same care and clean ingredients we give ourselves. That’s why our NAKED Organic Peanut Butter and single-serve packets (perfect for on-the-go snacks, or sneaking a pill into your pup’s treat) are just peanuts—nothing more.

Peanut butter has become a go-to treat for dog parents everywhere, whether it’s used to reward good behavior, hide medication, or keep pups entertained with enrichment toys. But when it comes to choosing the best peanut butter for dogs, safety matters just as much as taste. Many peanut butters on the market are made for humans, not pets, and can contain ingredients that are harmful to dogs if consumed.

That’s why understanding what makes peanut butter safe and what makes it dangerous is essential. In this guide, we’ll break down what to look for in peanut butter for dogs, which ingredients to avoid, and how to serve it responsibly so your dog can enjoy it safely and happily.

Xylitol is a sugar substitute commonly found in “sugar-free” or “low-calorie” peanut butters, baked goods, gum, and candy. While it’s safe for humans, xylitol is extremely toxic to dogs, even in very small amounts.

When dogs ingest xylitol, it can cause a rapid release of insulin, leading to dangerously low blood sugar levels. Symptoms can appear within minutes and may include vomiting, weakness, loss of coordination, seizures, or collapse. In severe cases, xylitol poisoning can lead to liver failure or death.

This is why reading the ingredient label is critical when choosing peanut butter for dogs. If you see xylitol listed, or anything labeled as a sugar substitute, that product should never be given to your dog.

When choosing peanut butter for your dog, steer clear of:

• Added sugar → contributes to obesity and tooth decay
• Palm oil → tough on digestion, can trigger pancreatitis
• Artificial preservatives → unnecessary and irritating
• Excess salt → can strain kidneys

Our philosophy at Spread The Love is simple: if it’s not good enough for our family, it’s not good enough for yours (dogs included). That’s why we’ve never added palm oil, fillers, or sweeteners.

When clean and simple, peanut butter is more than a tasty treat. It provides:

• Protein → supports muscle repair
• Healthy fats → keep skin soft and coats shiny
• Vitamin E & B vitamins → protect cells and fuel energy

Peanut butter should always be served in moderation. As a general rule, treats including peanut butter should make up no more than 10% of your dog’s daily calorie intake.

A helpful guideline by size:

• Small dogs: ½ to 1 teaspoon

• Medium dogs: 1 to 2 teaspoons

• Large dogs: up to 1 tablespoon

Every dog is different, so start small and observe how your dog responds before increasing portions.

The safest peanut butter for dogs is one with minimal ingredients. Ideally, it should contain just peanuts or peanuts with a small amount of salt. The fewer ingredients listed, the easier it is to know exactly what you’re giving your pup.

Natural peanut butter with clean ingredients helps ensure your dog gets a treat that’s simple, wholesome, and easy to digest.

At Spread The Love, our NAKED Organic Peanut Butter is made with just one ingredient, peanuts, making it a clean, xylitol-free option dog parents can feel confident sharing in small amounts.

Whether you’re scooping from a jar at home or using single-serve packets for convenience, choosing peanut butter with transparent ingredients helps protect your dog’s health while still letting them enjoy a treat they love.

Peanut butter for dogs isn’t just a snack, it’s a versatile enrichment tool. You can spread a thin layer inside puzzle toys, lick mats, or treat-dispensing toys to keep your dog mentally engaged and entertained.

It’s also commonly used to:

• Hide pills or supplements

• Create frozen treats during warmer months

• Add excitement to training rewards

Always be mindful of portion sizes, especially when peanut butter is used frequently for enrichment. Here are my favorite ways to give peanut butter to our pup:

• Stuff a KONG toy with Spread The Love for playtime enrichment
• Smear on a lick mat to reduce anxiety
• Freeze PB & Greek yogurt bites for a summer snack
• Hide medicine in a spoonful for stress-free dosing

Peanut butter can be a fun, rewarding, and enriching treat for dogs, as long as it’s chosen carefully and served in moderation. Understanding what ingredients to avoid is the most important step in keeping your dog safe, especially when it comes to xylitol.

Our pets give us unconditional love, and they deserve the same care we show our families. By choosing xylitol-free, sugar-free, and palm-oil-free peanut butter—like our Spread The Love NAKED Organic Peanut Butter—you’re treating your dog to pure, wholesome goodness.

Because when we say Spread The Love, we mean it—for people, for pups, for everyone at the table (or under it, waiting for a spoonful 😉).

Ready to treat your pup the clean way? Shop our NAKED Organic Peanut Butter or grab a box of PB Packets for snack-time convenience. If you are feeling like spoiling your dog, check out our Spread The Love Dog Lover Gift Set. It's perfect for any dog occasion like today!