2026 Holiday Gift Guide | Thoughtful Food Gifts & More
A thoughtful holiday gift guide featuring Spread The Love nut butters, artisan jams, gift sets, and cozy lifestyle favorites. From foodies and homebodies to fitness lovers and holiday hosts, discover delicious, meaningful gifts for everyone on your list. Because the best gifts are made to be shared!
Table of Contents
“The best gifts come from the heart. After all, that's how Spread The Love started.”
For the foodie, the homebody, the always-on-the-go friend, and everyone in between.
Some people are easy to shop for. Others have you scrolling through gift guides at midnight, wondering if another candle is really the answer.
This year, we're making gifting a little more personal (and a lot more delicious).
After all, Spread The Love started with a gift. Back in 2013, our founders Val and Zach made homemade peanut butter for their wedding guests. What began as a simple way to share something they loved turned into a family-owned food business built around the same idea: good food is meant to be shared.
So whether you're shopping for your best friend, the family foodie, or someone who's impossible to buy for, we've rounded up our favorite holiday gift ideas for 2026.
Consider this your permission to give something they'll actually use, love, and maybe not want to share.
1. Gifts For the Foodie Who Has Excellent Taste
They know the best brunch spot in town, have strong opinions about olive oil, and believe the best gifts are edible.
For this person, the pantry is more than a place to store groceries. It's a collection of little luxuries. Give them something that makes an ordinary Tuesday breakfast feel like a weekend brunch.
Our Spread The Love picks:
NAKED Organic Peanut Butter Glass: The same one-ingredient organic peanut butter they love, now in a beautiful glass jar. Pure roasted peanuts, naturally creamy, and made for drizzling.
Artisan Marionberry Jam: Rich, fruity, and made with simple ingredients. A delicious addition to cheese boards, pastries, and homemade PB&Js.
POWER Almond Cashew Butter: A smooth blend of almonds and cashews that's perfect for everything from overnight oats to dessert.
Pair them with:
A beautiful ceramic butter dish or handcrafted serving bowl
A cookbook filled with recipes worth bookmarking
High-quality olive oil or flaky finishing salt
2. Gifts For the Cozy Homebody
Their ideal Friday night involves soft pajamas, a good show, and absolutely no plans.
Some people want to go out. Others want to make their homes so comfortable that leaving feels unnecessary. We fully support the latter.
Think cozy mornings, slow breakfasts, and the kind of gifts that make staying in feel like a luxury.
Our Spread The Love picks:
UNSALTED Almond Butter: Made with just one ingredient: roasted almonds. Delicious on warm oatmeal, toast, pancakes, or straight from the spoon.
BASIC Cashew Butter: Smooth, naturally creamy, and a little indulgent. Perfect for cozy baking projects and homemade treats.
Spread The Love Pretty Ugly Sweater: For holiday movie marathons, cookie decorating, and festive gatherings.
Pair them with:
An oversized knit blanket
A cozy pair of slippers
A holiday-scented candle
3. Gifts For the Friend Who's Always on the Go
Their calendar is full, their water bottle goes everywhere, and they somehow squeeze a workout into every day.
For the friend who's always going somewhere, the best gifts make busy days just a little easier.
Whether they're heading to Pilates, catching a flight, or running from one errand to the next, give them something that fits their lifestyle.
Our Spread The Love picks:
NAKED Organic Peanut Butter Single-Serve Packets: One ingredient, seven grams of protein per serving, and perfectly portable.
UNSALTED Almond Butter Single-Serve Packets: Creamy almond butter in a convenient packet for snacking wherever the day takes them.
Spread The Love Red Tote Bag: A practical everyday carryall for groceries, workout essentials, and everything in between.
Pair them with:
A stylish insulated water bottle
A Pilates or yoga class pass
Headphones
A pair of cozy crew socks
A cute bag charm
4. Gifts For the Person Who Already Has Everything
They buy what they want, when they want it. Shopping for them is basically an Olympic sport.
What do you give someone who insists they don't need anything?
Something delicious, thoughtfully made, and just indulgent enough that they wouldn't necessarily buy it for themselves.
Our Spread The Love picks:
Spread The Love Gift Set: A beautifully packaged assortment of our favorite nut butters and artisan jams. The kind of gift that's ready to unwrap, open, and enjoy.
Custom Spread The Love Gift Set: Make gifting more personal by choosing a selection of spreads that matches their tastes.
NAKED Organic Peanut Butter in Glass: An elevated take on an everyday favorite, perfect for the person who appreciates quality ingredients and thoughtful details.
Pair them with:
A personalized cutting board
A luxurious hand soap or hand cream
An artisan coffee subscription
A handcrafted ceramic serving plate
A handwritten note (seriously, don't skip this one)
The gift we'd give: A customized Spread The Love Gift Set with a handwritten card. Because the best gifts aren't necessarily the most expensive. They're the ones that show you know someone.
5. Gifts For the One Who Loves Hosting
They own matching serving platters, always have snacks ready, and somehow make even a casual gathering feel special.
The holidays are their time to shine. From elaborate brunch spreads to casual wine nights, they're always finding a reason to bring people together.
Give them something worth putting on the table.
Our Spread The Love picks:
Artisan Raspberry Jam: Bright, fruity, and made with just two ingredients. Perfect for thumbprint cookies, holiday pastries, or a brunch spread.
Artisan Marionberry Jam: A delicious partner for soft cheeses, crackers, and homemade baked goods.
NAKED CRUNCH Organic Peanut Butter: A little crunch for breakfast boards, desserts, and satisfying snacks.
Pair them with:
A wooden charcuterie board
Linen cocktail napkins
A set of small ceramic serving bowls
A beautiful cake stand
A holiday entertaining cookbook
The gift we'd give: A pair of artisan jams, a mini serving board, and a handwritten recipe for your favorite holiday appetizer. Thoughtful, delicious, and ready for their next gathering.
6. Gifts For the Little Ones (and the Young at Heart)
They believe everything is better with a little fun.
Not every great gift needs to be serious. Sometimes you just need something adorable, unexpected, and guaranteed to make someone smile.
Our Spread The Love picks:
PBlushie Stuffie: A cuddly peanut butter-inspired companion for little Spread The Love fans and adults who appreciate a cute collectible.
NAKED Organic Peanut Butter: A family pantry favorite made with one ingredient and plenty of possibilities for delicious snacks.
Spread The Love Beanie: A cozy addition to winter outfits and holiday adventures.
Pair them with:
A holiday-themed picture book
A cookie decorating kit
Colorful fuzzy socks
A mini baking set
A fun reusable lunch bag
The gift we'd give: A PBlushie Stuffie alongside a homemade holiday cookie kit. It's a little sweet, a little silly, and a lot of fun.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Are Spread The Love products good for holiday gifting?
Absolutely! Our nut butters and artisan jams are made with simple, high-quality ingredients and no unnecessary additives. Whether you're shopping for a foodie, fitness enthusiast, teacher, or holiday host, they're a delicious way to show someone you care.
Can I create a personalized holiday gift set?
Yes! Mix and match your favorite Spread The Love nut butters and artisan jams to create a thoughtful assortment tailored to your recipient's tastes. It's a fun way to make holiday gifting feel more personal.
What are some affordable but thoughtful holiday gift ideas?
You don't need to spend a fortune to give a meaningful gift. Pair a jar of Spread The Love peanut butter with homemade cookies, a favorite recipe, or a handwritten note. Sometimes the simplest gifts are the sweetest.
About founder Val Fishbain
VAL FISHBAIN
Val Fishbain is the co-founder and President of Spread The Love Foods, a family-owned food brand that began in 2013 with 150 jars of homemade peanut butter gifted to wedding guests. What started as a heartfelt gesture grew into a mission to make everyday pantry staples with higher standards and simpler ingredients. With over a decade of experience in the food industry, Val brings her passion for quality, thoughtful gifting, and bringing people together to this holiday gift guide. After all, she knows firsthand that the best gifts are made with love.
SHOP OUR JARS AS HOLIDAY GIFTS
